Third-party driver insurance in Switzerland: the 2026 comparison for sharing a car with people you know
By Co-oto Last updated:
Read this first. This comparison is a snapshot as of October 17, 2026. Insurers regularly change their terms, their prices and the names of their products: what is true today may no longer be true tomorrow.
Every car-sharing situation is different. How often you drive, how you share costs, whether you live together, the type of vehicle, the driver’s age, the owner’s contract: each of these details can change the cover.
Before you rely on any insurance, describe your situation precisely to your insurer and ask for written confirmation. Only the general terms of your own contract are binding. This article helps you ask the right questions; it is not insurance advice.
Do you drive a parent’s, a neighbor’s or a friend’s car? In Switzerland, insurance follows the vehicle: the vehicle’s compulsory liability insurance in principle covers damage caused to other people, whichever authorized person is driving. Our guide to car sharing and insurance in Switzerland explains this legal foundation in detail.
What can get expensive is damage to the borrowed car, the deductible and the owner’s premium increase (malus). That is the job of the “driving third-party vehicles” option (also called third-party driver insurance, or Fremdlenkerversicherung in German), which you add to your private liability insurance.
We read the general terms and conditions (GTC) of 10 Swiss insurers and compared 11 offers to find out which one offers the best protection when you share a car regularly, week after week.
The essentials in 30 seconds
- Most options only cover occasional use: 6 to 35 days per year depending on the insurer. Borrowing twice a week adds up to about 100 days a year: standard cover no longer applies.
- Two offers accept regular use: Helvetia’s paid extension for third-party vehicles and Allianz’s Premium cover.
- Three exclusions come up almost everywhere: people living under the same roof, vehicles over 3.5 t (many motorhomes and vans) and trips made “for payment”.
- There is always a deductible, and driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs, or without a valid license, loses you the cover or lets the insurer reduce its benefits and claim the money back from you.
The ranking
Scores out of 10, weighted according to the criteria described below. This is Co-oto’s independent assessment based on the public GTC.
| Rank | Insurer and cover | Use allowed | Deductible | Indicative price | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Helvetia: third-party vehicles extension | No day limit | Per policy | n/a | 8.3 |
| 2 | Allianz: Premium cover | No limit | CHF 500 (CHF 1,000 under 25)¹ | CHF 150/year in 2016¹ | 8.0 |
| 3 | La Mobilière: included in private liability | 35 days/year (10 in the Minima plan) | Per policy | Included | 6.5 |
| 4 | Generali: paid option | 35 days/year | CHF 500 | n/a | 6.1 |
| 5 | Allianz: standard cover | Example: once a week for 2 months, or 1 week in a row | 10%, min. CHF 500, max. CHF 5,000 | from CHF 30/year | 5.7 |
| 5 | AXA: paid option | Occasional, no number of days | Per policy | approx. CHF 40/year² | 5.7 |
| 5 | CSS: paid option | 35 days/year | 10%, min. CHF 500 | n/a | 5.7 |
| 8 | Smile: paid option | 28 consecutive days at most | CHF 500 | n/a | 5.4 |
| 9 | Zurich: paid option | 25 days/year | CHF 200 (GTC) / CHF 500 (website)³ | n/a | 5.3 |
| 9 | Groupe Mutuel: SelfProtect option | 14 days/year | CHF 200 to 1,000 | n/a | 5.3 |
| 11 | Vaudoise: Home in One option | 14 days/year | Per policy | n/a | 4.8 |
¹ Figures from Allianz’s 2016 launch press release; the terms refer to the deductible in your policy, and the current rate is not published.
² Comparis estimate (2022).
³ The GTC set CHF 200 unless the policy specifies another deductible; Zurich’s website says “generally CHF 500”.
n/a = not publicly disclosed.
Not ranked: Visana (terms published: non-regular use, i.e. at most 24 days a year, deductible per policy; not scored, as we found its terms after closing the comparison), Baloise (merged with Helvetia: holding companies in December 2025, Swiss insurers on July 1, 2026; existing contracts remain valid), TCS (no private liability insurance in its range, as far as we know).
The criteria and their weight
| Criterion | Weight | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Regular use allowed | 30% | This is the point where cover breaks down when sharing among people you know. |
| Scope of cover | 20% | Damage to the vehicle, the owner’s deductible and malus, towing. |
| Restrictive exclusions | 20% | Same household and shared apartments, over 3.5 t, cost contributions, sharing platforms. |
| Deductible and limits | 15% | What you still pay yourself after a claim. |
| Price | 10% | Differences amount to a few dozen francs a year, against thousands for an uncovered claim. |
| Transparency | 5% | Clear thresholds, recent and accessible GTC, published price. |
Detailed scores (out of 10). When a price is not published, we assign a neutral score of 5.
| Insurer | Use | Cover | Exclusions | Deductible / limits | Price | Transparency | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Helvetia (extension) | 10 | 9 | 8 | 7 | 5 | 6 | 8.3 |
| Allianz Premium | 10 | 9 | 7 | 7 | 5 | 4 | 8.0 |
| La Mobilière | 6 | 8 | 5 | 6 | 9 | 5 | 6.5 |
| Generali | 6 | 7 | 5 | 6 | 5 | 9 | 6.1 |
| Allianz Standard | 4 | 8 | 5 | 5 | 9 | 5 | 5.7 |
| AXA | 4 | 9 | 4 | 6 | 8 | 4 | 5.7 |
| CSS | 6 | 7 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 8 | 5.7 |
| Smile | 4 | 8 | 4 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 5.4 |
| Zurich | 5 | 7 | 3 | 6 | 5 | 7 | 5.3 |
| Groupe Mutuel | 3 | 7 | 6 | 6 | 5 | 7 | 5.3 |
| Vaudoise | 3 | 6 | 6 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 4.8 |
The gap between Helvetia and Allianz Premium (0.3 points) is smaller than the margin of uncertainty in our scores: we consider them two equivalent first choices, to be decided according to your situation (see below).
Insurer by insurer
Under each insurer, the line in italics gives the document and the clause to quote when you contact your insurer.
1. Helvetia: the only one that covers shared apartments
Source: GTC household contents and private liability, September 2025 edition, extension A35.1.
Helvetia’s basic cover is the most restrictive in this comparison: “occasional” use is capped at 6 days a year. But its paid extension changes everything: it sets no day limit, and Helvetia presents it for anyone who “regularly uses their parents’ or acquaintances’ car”. It covers three situations:
- a car lent to you free of charge by someone you know;
- a car shared between roommates, a case excluded everywhere else;
- commercial car-sharing, rental or garage cars, with damage covered up to CHF 2,500.
What it covers: collision damage that the vehicle’s liability insurance does not pay for, the owner’s deductible and loss of bonus, and towing to the nearest garage. If the car has casco cover, only the deductible and the malus are reimbursed.
Exclusions: vehicles over 3.5 t; a car belonging to a family member or partner living under the same roof; your employer’s car; trips for payment or for work; loss of value.
Weak point: the price is not published (online calculator only), and the deductible depends on your policy.
2. Allianz Premium: unlimited, car sharing included
Source: supplementary terms “Premium driver cover”, September 2016 edition.
The Premium cover has no occasional-use limit: removing it was precisely the point of its launch in 2016. It covers damage to the borrowed car, the owner’s deductible and malus and, unusually, the deductible of the vehicle’s liability insurance. Rental cars are excluded; car-sharing services are covered.
Exclusions: vehicles over 3.5 t; your own vehicles and your employer’s (in practice, also those of people in your household); trips for payment or for work; replacement vehicle, downtime and loss of value. Your deductible applies only to damage to the borrowed car.
Weak points: its terms date from 2016, and the only known figures (CHF 150 a year, deductible of CHF 500, or CHF 1,000 under 25) come from the launch press release. Ask for the current rate.
3. La Mobilière: included by default, but occasional
Source: GTC household and private liability, April 2025 edition, art. 11; Mobilière guide, October 2026.
It is the insurer that includes the most generous cover by default in basic private liability insurance: nothing to add (Helvetia also includes one, but limited to 6 days). It covers collision damage to the borrowed car, the deductible and the malus if casco cover pays out, plus a replacement vehicle up to CHF 1,000 per claim.
Limits: 35 days per calendar year, reduced to 10 days in the entry-level “Minima” plan, which also has no replacement vehicle; free use only, as trips for payment are excluded; vehicles up to 3.5 t; rental and leased cars excluded; cars with EU plates: cover capped at CHF 20,000 (CHF 10,000 in the Minima plan) and only for a claim in Switzerland or Liechtenstein; same household excluded; loss of value and downtime excluded.
4. Generali: clear rules
Source: GTC household insurance, 2026 edition, option B3.1.
An option you add to your contract, limited to 35 days per calendar year, consecutive or not. It covers liability on top of the vehicle’s own, loss of bonus up to 200% of the annual premium, the deductible of the vehicle’s liability insurance up to CHF 1,000, the casco deductible if there is one, and collision damage to the car. Deductible of CHF 500, unless the policy sets another amount.
Exclusions: rental cars and cars used regularly or for profit; a car provided by your employer or by another person insured under the same contract (so members of your household); deductibles not covered if the driver does not yet hold a permanent Swiss license; over 3.5 t. A separate option covers rental and commercial car sharing.
5. Allianz Standard: the cheapest, for truly occasional use
Source: GTC combined household insurance, March 2025 edition, art. D3.18.
From CHF 30 a year (Allianz’s example: age 45, in Zurich, 10% deductible, min. CHF 500, max. CHF 5,000). It covers damage to the borrowed car, the casco deductible and the owner’s malus. Occasional use is not defined in days; the terms give an example: at most once a week for two months, or one week in a row.
Exclusions: car-sharing services, rental companies and garages; trips for payment or for work; the deductible of the vehicle’s liability insurance; your own vehicles, your employer’s and, through the general exclusions, those of the people you live with; over 3.5 t; loss of value and downtime. Allianz’s guide nevertheless states that sharing between neighbors or people you know, without a commercial provider, is covered.
5. AXA: broad benefits, for occasional use only
Source: GTC household insurance, April 2020 edition (the most recent we found), option C1.
AXA sets no number of days, but excludes rental cars and cars used for payment through car sharing, and states on its website that the cover does not apply if you share the car regularly. Its benefits are among the broadest: liability on top of the vehicle’s own, loss of bonus, collision damage not covered by casco, towing, recovery and replacement vehicle, wrong fuel, cargo, soiling.
Exclusions: a car registered in the name of someone in your household; rental cars, or cars leased in your own name; professional use; cars used for car sharing. AXA defines car sharing as use for payment via an online platform: a simple loan between people who know each other falls outside that definition; get cost sharing confirmed all the same. Price not published; Comparis estimated the option at around forty francs a year in 2022.
5. CSS: a clear cap, strictly free use
Source: GTC private liability, February 2024 edition, section 22 a.
A paid option, 35 days per calendar year. It covers damage to the borrowed car up to CHF 50,000 per claim or, if casco cover exists, its deductible and the loss of bonus. Deductible of 10%, at least CHF 500.
Conditions and exclusions: the owner must not live under the same roof, be your employer or be a rental company; occasional, non-regular and free use; car registered in Switzerland; rental and car-sharing cars excluded; trips for payment excluded; over 3.5 t; loss of value, downtime and replacement vehicle excluded.
8. Smile: good benefits, limited duration
Source: GTC smile.home, January 2024 edition, option P.3.1.
A paid option for occasional drivers, limited to 28 consecutive days. Without casco cover, it pays for repairs, plus towing and parking fees up to CHF 500; with casco, the deductible and the malus. In both cases, a replacement vehicle up to CHF 1,000 per claim. Deductible of CHF 500 per claim.
Exclusions: rental and shared cars; trips for payment; your employer’s car; over 3.5 t; and, through the general exclusions, damage affecting your roommates. Watch out: the terms promise a replacement vehicle, then exclude the same costs a few lines further down; get this point clarified before you sign up.
9. Zurich: watch out for platforms
Source: GCI household insurance, May 2026 edition, art. 701 and 613 g.
A paid option, 25 days per calendar year. It covers damage to the borrowed car or, if there is collision casco cover, the deductible and the malus. Deductible of CHF 200 according to the general conditions, unless your policy sets another amount; Zurich’s website says “generally” CHF 500.
Exclusions: same household; professional use and employer cars; leasing and subscriptions; and above all cars booked with a car-sharing company or via a sharing platform and driven or borrowed for a fee. These words describe paid bookings; a free loan between people who know each other, organized with an app, sits apart. The terms leave “fee” undefined, though: if you share costs, get the cover confirmed in writing.
9. Groupe Mutuel: only 14 days
Source: GTC SelfProtect, January 2022 edition, art. 20 (the insurer behind the offer is Vaudoise).
A paid option limited to occasional, short-term use: 14 days per calendar year at most. It covers accidental damage to the car (up to CHF 50,000 per claim according to the flyer), damage during loading and unloading and, where casco cover exists, the deductible and the premium surcharge. Deductible: CHF 200, 500 or 1,000, matching the one chosen for the basic contract.
Exclusions: cars belonging to an employer, a professional rental company or the motor trade; loss of value and replacement vehicle; USA and Canada; over 3.5 t; and, through the general exclusions, damage suffered by someone in your household.
11. Vaudoise: the same text, less precise
Source: GTC Home in One, January 2023 edition, option C2.
The text is almost identical to Groupe Mutuel’s, whose insurer Vaudoise is: 14 days per calendar year, deductible and malus covered where casco cover exists, same exclusions (employer, rental companies, loss of value, USA and Canada). The cap and the deductible do not appear in the general terms (“per policy”), and we did not find a more recent edition.
Three traps to check before you sign
1. Cost sharing. Most GTC require “free” use or exclude trips “for payment” (Groupe Mutuel and Vaudoise only require non-regular use). None of them specifies whether reimbursing the owner for fuel, kilometers or a share of fixed costs counts as payment. Swiss law in principle accepts that a contribution to costs does not turn a loan into a rental (we explain it here), but what counts is your insurer’s reading. Describe your arrangement to your insurer and ask for written confirmation.
2. The same household. If you live with the owner (couple, family, shared apartment), the third-party driver option generally does not apply. The right solution is then to be declared as a driver on the owner’s policy. Only Helvetia explicitly covers shared apartments through its extension.
3. Vehicles over 3.5 t. None of the insurers compared covers them. For a large motorhome or a heavy van, only the owner’s casco insurance protects you.
Our recommendation
If you borrow a vehicle more than two or three times a month, choose an option that accepts regular use:
- Helvetia if you share an apartment with the owner, or if you want recent terms;
- Allianz Premium if you also use commercial car-sharing services and want no cap on damage for those trips (Helvetia covers them up to CHF 2,500).
In both cases, ask for the current price and the terms in force before you sign.
If you borrow rarely, the option in your current private liability insurance is probably enough. Check how many days it allows: it ranges from 6 to 35 depending on the insurer.
On the owner’s side, the foundation remains full casco cover (ideally with gross negligence cover and bonus protection), and declaring regular drivers to your insurer.
In every case, agree in writing between yourselves on who pays the deductible and the malus after a claim: our car-sharing agreement generator includes that clause. To place your own situation in two minutes, take the “Am I covered?” test.
Important reminder. The information in this article is general and may have changed since publication. It does not take into account the specifics of your situation. Contact your insurer, describe precisely how you share the vehicle (frequency, people, cost sharing, type of vehicle, app used) and get written confirmation before you hit the road. Only the general terms of your own contract are binding.
Method and sources
Comparison carried out in October 2026 from each insurer’s public general terms, using for each the cover best suited to regular use. The scores reflect our reading of the texts; they do not replace the terms of your contract. Co-oto has no commercial partnership with the insurers mentioned. Most of the linked documents exist only in French or German.
- Allianz: GTC Kombi-Haushalt 03/2025 (German) · Supplementary terms, Premium driver cover 09.2016 (French) · Third-party driver insurance guide · 2016 launch press release (German)
- Helvetia: GTC household contents and private liability 09.2025 (French) · Non-owner car insurance guide
- La Mobilière: GTC household and private liability 04.2025 (German) · GTC Minima 04.2025 (German) · Guide (French)
- Generali: GTC household 2026 (French)
- AXA: GTC household 04.2020 (German) · Third-party driver insurance page
- CSS: GTC private liability 02.2024 (German)
- Smile: GTC smile.home 2024 (French)
- Zurich: GCI Household Insurance 05/2026
- Groupe Mutuel: GTC SelfProtect 01.2022 (French) · Flyer 9.24 (French)
- Vaudoise: GTC Home in One 01.2023 (French)
- Comparis: AXA indicative price (German)
Going further
Related resources
Sharing between private owners
The tools that prevent misunderstandings in a circle.
ReadThe trip logbook
Record your trips, your mileage and your exports.
ReadHow much to charge per kilometer?
The right rate, tax caps and pitfalls, country by country.
ReadCo-oto vs rental platforms
Getaround, GoMore and Turo compared with sharing among people you know.
Read